Updated 2018-08-17 21:26:33 by AMG

AMG: try and throw are very nice to have, but they are new to Tcl 8.6. Here are Tcl 8.5-compatible implementations that pass the 8.6.8 test suite:
proc try {args} {
    # Require at least one argument.
    if {![llength $args]} {
        throw {TCL WRONGARGS} "wrong # args: should be\
                \"try body ?handler ...? ?finally script?\""

    # Scan arguments.
    set args [lassign $args body]
    set handlers {}
    while {[llength $args]} {
        set args [lassign $args type]
        switch $type {
        on {
            if {[llength $args] < 3} {
                throw {TCL OPERATION TRY ON ARGUMENT} "wrong # args to on\
                        clause: must be \"... on code variableList script\""
            set args [lassign $args code variableList script]
            if {![string is integer -strict $code]} {
                if {[regexp {^[ \f\n\r\t\v]*[-+]?\d+[ \f\n\r\t\v]*$} $code]
                 || [set newCode [lsearch -exact\
                            {ok error return break continue} $code]] < 0} {
                    throw {TCL RESULT ILLEGAL_CODE} "bad completion code\
                            \"$code\": must be ok, error, return, break,\
                            continue, or an integer"
                set code $newCode
            lappend handlers on $code $variableList $script
        } trap {
            if {[llength $args] < 3} {
                throw {TCL OPERATION TRY TRAP ARGUMENT} "wrong # args to\
                        trap clause: must be \"... trap pattern\
                        variableList script\""
            set args [lassign $args pattern variableList script]
            if {[catch {list {*}$pattern} pattern]} {
                throw {TCL OPERATION TRY TRAP EXNFORMAT} "bad prefix\
                        '$pattern': must be a list"
            lappend handlers trap $pattern $variableList $script
        } finally {
            if {![llength $args]} {
                throw {TCL OPERATION TRY FINALLY ARGUMENT} "wrong # args\
                        to finally clause: must be \"... finally script\""
            set args [lassign $args finally]
            if {[llength $args]} {
                throw {TCL OPERATION TRY FINALLY NONTERMINAL} "finally\
                        clause must be last"
        } default {
            throw [list TCL LOOKUP INDEX {handler type} $type] "bad handler\
                    type \"$type\": must be finally, on, or trap"
    if {[info exists script] && $script eq "-"} {
        throw {TCL OPERATION TRY BADFALLTHROUGH} "last non-finally clause must\
                not have a body of \"-\""

    # Evaluate the script body and intercept errors.
    set code [catch {uplevel 1 $body} result options]

    # Search for and evaluate the first matching handler.
    foreach {type pattern varList script} $handlers {
        if {![info exists next] && ($type ne "on" || $pattern != $code)
         && ($type ne "trap" || ![dict exists $options -errorcode]
          || $pattern ne [lrange [dict get $options -errorcode]\
                0 [expr {[llength $pattern] - 1}]])} {
            # Skip this handler if it doesn't match.
        } elseif {$script eq "-"} {
            # If the script is "-", evaluate the next handler script that is not
            # "-", regardless of the match criteria.
            set next {}
        } else {
            # Evaluate the handler script and intercept errors.
            if {[catch {
                if {[llength $varList] >= 1} {
                    uplevel 1 [list set [lindex $varList 0] $result]
                if {[llength $varList] >= 2} {
                    uplevel 1 [list set [lindex $varList 1] $options]
                uplevel 1 $script
            } result newOptions] && [dict exists $newOptions -errorcode]} {
                dict set newOptions -during $options
            set options $newOptions

            # Stop after evaluating the first matching handler script.

    # Evaluate the finally clause and intercept errors.
    if {[info exists finally]
     && [catch {uplevel 1 $finally} newResult newOptions]} {
        if {[dict exists $newOptions -errorcode]} {
            dict set newOptions -during $options
        set options $newOptions
        set result $newResult

    # Return any errors generated by the handler scripts.
    dict incr options -level
    return {*}$options $result

proc throw {type message} {
    if {![llength $type]} {
        return -code error -errorcode {TCL OPERATION THROW BADEXCEPTION}\
                "type must be non-empty list"
    } else {
        return -code error -errorcode $type $message

Equivalent functionality is available in the "try" module of tcllib: [1] [2]. To be honest, I prefer my version. It looks cleaner to me, it exactly matches the error messages produced by Tcl 8.6.8, and it passes the test suite.